C.J. Cherryh, Downbelow Station

C. J. Cherry‘s Downbelow Station is old enough to be safely called a “classic”. It won the Hugo for best novel in 1982. According to Wikipedia, Locus Magazine in 1987 considered it among the top 50 science fiction novels of all time. Recently, maybe obscured by the bulk of its sequels, the book doesn’t seem to get quite that level of adulation. The Guardians recent 1000 Must-Read Novels list contained maybe 140 SF books and left this one out, though they included a few more recent novels (for example, Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell) that I don’t expect will stand the test of time as well as Cherryh’s.

It is probably those sequels that have kept me from reading this for so long. I’ve been aware of the book, and seen it recommended, for probably 15 years. But I’ve never felt I could spare the decade I’d need to read it and its more than 20(!) sequels.

The book starts with a long-view history of space exploration by the commercially motivated Earth Company and the founding of various stations colonies, leading to the point where the colonies surpass the homeworld in technology, and become divorced from it in culture. Finally the Beyond forms its own government, called Union, and rebels against the Company. Years later, the central story starts as the Earth space fleet is reduced to a few harried ships, and Union is on the brink of taking over all the known worlds.

The story involves the Union advance on Pell’s World, the closest station to Earth, and one of very few (maybe only two) to be in a system that also contains an inhabited planet. Multiple factions vie for control of the station, and most of them are ruthless enough to destroy the station if that’s the only way to keep it out of the hands of their rivals. Refugees from other recently captured or destroyed stations crowd Pell’s, creating an extra set of problems for Pell’s more benevolent leaders who are the most sympathetic characters we see. Frustratingly, the story basically ends in a stand-off, brokered by the space merchant (“merchanters”) faction, creating a balance of power that presumably sets the stage for all those sequels.

On the other hand, what the novel has going for it is an intense pace that kept me engaged throughout. By keeping each chapter focussed on the viewpoint of one character, we appreciate the motivations of even the least sympathetic characters. There are few villains here, aside from a clan of self-serving Pell aristocrats who are only minor players in the multi-sided conflict between Union, Company, fleet, station, and merchanters. And for the more appealing characters, the focussed narration creates a strong identification with their difficulties and moral dilemmas.

I don’t know of another author who can match Cherryh’s combination of characterization and intense narrative. Richard K. Morgan delivers a wilder roller-coaster ride of a story, but builds it mostly on explicit violence and cardboard characters. Neal Stephenson can also combine an intense story and interesting characters, but his intensity always seems to come somewhat tongue-in-cheek. Cherryh’s narrative rarely takes a break for humor, keeping a relatively serious tone, even if her themes are perhaps not earthshakingly weighty.

Overall, an enjoyable read, and well worth the time spent, especially for the experience of Cherryh’s unique narrative voice.


2 Responses to “C.J. Cherryh, Downbelow Station

  1. Linda Palapala Says:

    Funny you should mention two of my favorite authors in your review of Downbelow Station. For many years C J Cherryh was my favorite author. I’d read her Morgaine Trilogy every year for at least 10 years. She writes beautifully. However, once I read Richard Morgan’s books, he instantly became my favorite author.

    I totally disagree with your assessment his characters are cardboard. They are emotional, human with human flaws. His books go much deeper than just violence, and just one point of view. I love his exploration of socio-political, religious views – they give me lots to think about. In fact, now that I’ve read Richard’s books, I was shocked to find Cherryh’s books seem very juvenile and immature (which was fine when I was younger and more immature).

    Back to Downbelow Station: Yes, very good book, I still do like her style of writing.

  2. mattbruensteiner Says:

    I should have admitted that Altered Carbon is the only Richard K. Morgan book I’ve read. I didn’t find the characters particularly deep in that book, but his later books might have done much more in this dimension.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: